2019 certainly wasn't a good season for the Colts, regardless of what you use to measure them, but was it a total failure? It probably depends on who you ask. A team that entered the season with most national prognosticators predicting around seven wins ended up with seven wins. A promising 5-2 start quickly dissolved thanks to kicking woes (which, incredibly, they were able to somehow overcome early), key injuries, and mediocre to downright bad quarterback play.
So, adding everything up, what grade would you give the 2019 Colts? Select your grade in our Twitter poll: